Blood on the Clocktower

[Annoying Prick]

Since Agent's accusation of Aragorn rests on the assumption I was the Minion 

It doesn't, read my post again, I outlined every logical possibility, even the most unlikely ones for anyone still unconvinced.

I was confused by "the most likely" following the scenario where I am the Minion. So you believe that Aragorn is the Imp and Duck is the Minion or Null is the Imp and Duck is the Minion.

I guess it could be true. I'd like to know how Star can be sure you're town. Even if he's the washerwoman judging by the role rules you could have just bluffed your way into him accepting you as the confirmed town as he is not given a definite player for the role and you haven't role claimed publicly.

[Annoying Prick]

Since Agent's accusation of Aragorn rests on the assumption I was the Minion then I can't offer my dead vote against him, at least not without better evidence that Agent is town.

Honestly I've missed where he said this. Maybe it's just the thread being pretty active but I saw him listing Duck as the minion.

Going to double post because it's the easiest way to respond.

He said "If Duck's role claim is true (it isn't), this still only leaves Aragorn/Prick as demon/minion. The most likely." I think I misread this and he meant to say that the impossibility of me being the Minion makes Duck being the Minion more likely.

[Dirty Duck]

I was against votes on Gorm because who else did I investigate on night 1? I also explained my reason for investigating you both nights, the idea was so that I would know exactly who the demon was when I got a positive read, the way the seer would.

[Agent]

Since Agent's accusation of Aragorn rests on the assumption I was the Minion 

It doesn't, read my post again, I outlined every logical possibility, even the most unlikely ones for anyone still unconvinced.

I was confused by "the most likely" following the scenario where I am the Minion. So you believe that Aragorn is the Imp and Duck is the Minion or Null is the Imp and Duck is the Minion.

Yeah I meant that number 1 was the most likely scenario, and even if you were the minion (I know you're not), Aragorn is still most likely to be the demon. Null could be the demon too, on paper, but i'm not covering all the other sussy posting from Aragorn/Duck because we have enough factual info to make the call at this point. 

I have soft role claimed and Star knows this. Unsure why he's still reluctant to vote.

[Annoying Prick]

Since Agent's accusation of Aragorn rests on the assumption I was the Minion 

It doesn't, read my post again, I outlined every logical possibility, even the most unlikely ones for anyone still unconvinced.

I was confused by "the most likely" following the scenario where I am the Minion. So you believe that Aragorn is the Imp and Duck is the Minion or Null is the Imp and Duck is the Minion.

Yeah I meant that number 1 was the most likely scenario, and even if you were the minion (I know you're not), Aragorn is still most likely to be the demon. Null could be the demon too, on paper, but i'm not covering all the other sussy posting from Aragorn/Duck because we have enough factual info to make the call at this point. 

I have soft role claimed and Star knows this. Unsure why he's still reluctant to vote.

The thing is you only soft role claimed after he had already said that either you or Aragorn are confirmed town. You didn't actually provide any new information, potentially you just took the opportunity he gave you to lie. On top of that you haven't actually said the role so Star doesn't actually know that you even know what role he imagines you to be. I think the smart thing to do would be for you to role claim first and then for him to confirm or deny your stated role after that. If you are reluctant to do that then I would ask why.

Although I will say it is very suspicious that Aragorn has made no effort to counter-claim since if you are confirmed to be town then it immediately makes him suspicious. Granted you could both be town.

[Jassassino]

I was against votes on Gorm because who else did I investigate on night 1? I also explained my reason for investigating you both nights, the idea was so that I would know exactly who the demon was when I got a positive read, the way the seer would.

Day 1 prior to your investigation though you went for Null, not saying Null as a player in particular shows any indication of guilt, but it was between him, Gorn and Agent.

[Agent]

Since Agent's accusation of Aragorn rests on the assumption I was the Minion 

It doesn't, read my post again, I outlined every logical possibility, even the most unlikely ones for anyone still unconvinced.

I was confused by "the most likely" following the scenario where I am the Minion. So you believe that Aragorn is the Imp and Duck is the Minion or Null is the Imp and Duck is the Minion.

Yeah I meant that number 1 was the most likely scenario, and even if you were the minion (I know you're not), Aragorn is still most likely to be the demon. Null could be the demon too, on paper, but i'm not covering all the other sussy posting from Aragorn/Duck because we have enough factual info to make the call at this point. 

I have soft role claimed and Star knows this. Unsure why he's still reluctant to vote.

The thing is you only soft role claimed after he had already said that either you or Aragorn are confirmed town. You didn't actually provide any new information, potentially you just took the opportunity he gave you to lie. On top of that you haven't actually said the role so Star doesn't actually know that you even know what role he imagines you to be. I think the smart thing to do would be for you to role claim first and then for him to confirm or deny your stated role after that. If you are reluctant to do that then I would ask why.

The info I gave could only refer to one role. I've already reposted it once. You have the right thought process though.

[Dirty Duck]

I was against votes on Gorm because who else did I investigate on night 1? I also explained my reason for investigating you both nights, the idea was so that I would know exactly who the demon was when I got a positive read, the way the seer would.

Day 1 prior to your investigation though you went for Null, not saying Null as a player in particular shows any indication of guilt, but it was between him, Gorn and Agent.

I'm confused what you're getting at, I thought Null acted most suspiciously on day 1

EDIT: and in the end it was me who told him to role claim to save himself, which in the end was why he survived and Agent, who'd been totally apathetic towards whether Null died or not, voted no. I don't see what about my actions towards Null on day 1 you have an issue with

[Annoying Prick]

It doesn't, read my post again, I outlined every logical possibility, even the most unlikely ones for anyone still unconvinced.

I was confused by "the most likely" following the scenario where I am the Minion. So you believe that Aragorn is the Imp and Duck is the Minion or Null is the Imp and Duck is the Minion.

Yeah I meant that number 1 was the most likely scenario, and even if you were the minion (I know you're not), Aragorn is still most likely to be the demon. Null could be the demon too, on paper, but i'm not covering all the other sussy posting from Aragorn/Duck because we have enough factual info to make the call at this point. 

I have soft role claimed and Star knows this. Unsure why he's still reluctant to vote.

The thing is you only soft role claimed after he had already said that either you or Aragorn are confirmed town. You didn't actually provide any new information, potentially you just took the opportunity he gave you to lie. On top of that you haven't actually said the role so Star doesn't actually know that you even know what role he imagines you to be. I think the smart thing to do would be for you to role claim first and then for him to confirm or deny your stated role after that. If you are reluctant to do that then I would ask why.

The info I gave could only refer to one role. I've already reposted it once. You have the right thought process though.

Star asked for you to cite the post where you confirmed your role and you just posted a post where you are "relatively positive" about the innocence of Star and Jassassino, after Star had already role claimed. I am just struggling to work out why that should be a reveal for your role. If you feel that your role should be that obvious from the post then I don't understand why you can't openly claim it.

I would vote Aragorn if I was confident you were town. Obviously Star should if he is confident that you are.

[Null]

Damn son. Lots of interesting statements. Lots of projected confidence.

Right now a lot of this hinges on Agent’s role lining up with Star’s information, but that hasn’t actually been clearly stated or confirmed.

If Star has a specific role in mind, I think it’s better to either have Agent fully claim first or have Star confirm it, otherwise we’re making a decision based on something that hasn’t really been proven.

I’m not convinced we should be locking in Aragorn as the execution until that’s cleared up.