Blood on the Clocktower

[starschwar]

I'll review it before using this ruleset again. I did way better with "normal" mafia during The Matrix version.

[Annoying Prick]

Thanks for the game Wayno, hadn't played this variant before.

Prick and Star, i'd urge you to flick through the thread again when you get the chance, there were some mistakes and misunderstandings of the game to reflect on for next time.

GGs Duck and Aragorn for keeping it together

Is there anything you're referring to specifically besides me not understanding your role claim? I didn't understand what a "neighbour" referred to but I also feel that misunderstanding that didn't necessarily reflect a misunderstanding of the basic rules. I was just being stupid and couldn't put what you were describing to a role description despite reading all of the role list through.

[Agent]

Thanks for the game Wayno, hadn't played this variant before.

Prick and Star, i'd urge you to flick through the thread again when you get the chance, there were some mistakes and misunderstandings of the game to reflect on for next time.

GGs Duck and Aragorn for keeping it together

Is there anything you're referring to specifically besides me not understanding your role claim? I didn't understand what a "neighbour" referred to but I also feel that misunderstanding that didn't necessarily reflect a misunderstanding of the basic rules. I was just being stupid and couldn't put what you were describing to a role description despite reading all of the role list through.

No I don't mean that. The person in Star's role would have known with 100% certainty that I was innocent by that last day (if not days before) and would have come to my defense. This didn't happen so it didn't matter, but it would have been difficult to overturn the vote since you committed your dead vote before he posted. Not a big deal i'm just trying to be constructive, I don't think you could have changed the outcome yourself.

[Null]

bro's saying git gud

[Wayno]

Any questions about the game just gone or in general ask away.

[Dirty Duck]

Any questions about the game just gone or in general ask away.

Favourite colour?

[Wayno]

Any questions about the game just gone or in general ask away. I wouldn't want anyone put off from playing again because they thought they "did badly" in their first game of a new script.

[Annoying Prick]

@Agent I did say to Duck in a text conversation afterwards that it was funny that Star voted against you as if he had been one of the first to vote then it automatically would have called into question the narrative that you were both evil. I was just very confident you were the Imp at that point. I don't even know how I would have reacted to seeing Star's vote.

At any rate I don't think how I acted on the last day was a product of misunderstanding the rules. I was confident you were the Imp and I was confident Star would behave in a way that would reflect that. It was just bad deduction.