Mafia 1988: MGSF Legends

[Dirty Duck]

We have never explicitly used the logic before that the day one lynch train can't all be mafia. But by now it has become standard that the mafia avoid the bandwagon if they can. If we are guessing between Prick and Roger i'd lean towards the former. I'd like Roy and weavo to post first ideally to check the two role claims aren't contested.

@Roy @weavo are you The Repairman or The Observer? Just say yes or no, don't reveal what role you actually are if you're not one of these two.

[Agent]

What’s the reasoning you suspect Prick more Agent? Cause honestly just by pure ambiguity Roger seems more sus to me lol, but these are just pure vibes.

If Roger was the one holding up the start of day 2, he probably has an active townie night role. If he was mafia they'd have acted on his behalf if they thought he might be AWOL. Prick's probabilities also don't make sense, where he claims lynching an Aragorn voter would be statistically better. I don't know how Roger normally posts so idk what to make of him.

I'll lynch Prick and check back in the morning.

[Null]

I have PTSD from Max making previously strong and confident arguments and it’s flaring up majorly here.

@Mr. Tibbs what are you saying Repairman? Has your mind been changed?

[Annoying Prick]

I'm going to bed soon. I'd like to withdraw my Starschwar vote if that's okay since it's got messy and I want to wait for all potential role claims and don't want people to come on in six hours and see me potentially voting for a confirmed town. If I'm alive in the morning I'll review my vote then.

[weavo]

We have never explicitly used the logic before that the day one lynch train can't all be mafia. But by now it has become standard that the mafia avoid the bandwagon if they can. If we are guessing between Prick and Roger i'd lean towards the former. I'd like Roy and weavo to post first ideally to check the two role claims aren't contested.

@Roy @weavo are you The Repairman or The Observer? Just say yes or no, don't reveal what role you actually are if you're not one of these two.

nope

[Roger]

Well repairman can only fix someone once, they are basically fodder at this point. And frankly, I say we keep active people alive. I have no qualms here but the game must move forward.

LYNCH ROY

[starschwar]

We have never explicitly used logic before

This is more like it

I'm still undecided on what to do next, let me see what everyone else has to contribute.

[Mr. Tibbs]

I have PTSD from Max making previously strong and confident arguments and it’s flaring up majorly here.

@Mr. Tibbs what are you saying Repairman? Has your mind been changed?

I don't really know tbh. To be 100% real for a second I only voted to lynch duck because it seemed extreme and likely to generate some conversation. I wanted to see if anyone would be a little overeager to agree with me but it didn't really pan out.

For now I'm going to say Unlynch Dirty Duck

[Roger]

Also, I just have to ask. I was thinking of putting my avatar as some random anime babe. Would that have affected the "Roger" character in the video @bigboss88

[bigboss88]

Also, I just have to ask. I was thinking of putting my avatar as some random anime babe. Would that have affected the "Roger" character in the video @bigboss88

Yes, it would have.