Mafia 1988: MGSF Legends

[Aragorn]

Told ya, he was too absent.

[Dirty Duck]

You know, the lynch screen with all of us saluting. Duck's wearing a glove so it kinda looks like we're all saluting and he's pointing a gun to his head.

I made your vision a reality, BK. RIP 🫡

[Mr. Tibbs]

Man I actually really thought null was mafia and was planning a lynch train and now nobody will believe me

[Roger]

Also I think that both Null(member) and Annoying Prick(member) quickly switching to me, should prove that I am Town.

[starschwar]

Oh, the movie references in this thread are sublime! The Killer - and now Kill Bill!  By the way, the recent Whole Bloody Affair version is a must-watch, especially if you never got your hands on the Japanese DVDs back in the day.  Transformative experience, probably the definitive cut of the films.

Spoiler:

But I do miss Sonny Chiba's line about revenge not being a straight line.  Not sure why Tarantino deleted it. 

[bigboss88]

NIGHT 3 — THE DUCKLING’S NIGHTMARE

Night fell over MGSF, and things were getting increasingly embarrassing for the remaining Mafia.

Dirty Duck was still processing the shocking discovery that the Mafia had finally caught up to him. Apparently, being a moderator didn’t come with a complimentary threat-detection system.

But that wasn’t the only surprise waiting for him.

He was also about to discover the true identity of BLACK KING — THE FINAL MODERATOR! AND BOY HE WAS SO SHOCKED OF WHO HE WAS!

Meanwhile, everyone else was busy playing the hero. Investigations were launched, plans were made, suspicious people were watched, and several members probably accomplished absolutely nothing.

The Town was working tirelessly to save itself.

Unfortunately, all that hard work produced exactly ZERO FRUITS.

Then Black King stepped forward, delivering a message that sounded less like a threat and more like a disappointed father addressing his children:

“Will Town be able to figure out who I am? Will Town prevent another two members from falling down? I’m afraid the blood of the next two members will be on your hands, duckling!”

Silence.

Dirty Duck stared at the screen.

Two more members?

The final moderator?

And why was everyone suddenly calling him duckling?

For the first time in MGSF history, the duck wasn’t quacking.

He was sweating.

NIGHT 3 ENDS.

DAY 4 BEGINS!

Dead:-
Black king = Roy
Annoying Prick = Null
Null = Dirty Duck
Dirty Duck = Agent

[Aragorn]

I checked Agent. He's innocent.

List remaining:
Me
Tibbs
Starch
Agent
Roger
Roy
Weavo

Unconfirmed triage is Roger, Roy and Weavo.

Lynch Weavo.

We either win now or we know the final mafia tomorrow via process of elimination.

[weavo]

I mean sure you can vote for me - if you want to fall for Roger's trick. I'm 90% sure Prick only switched votes to him as some kind of innocence gambit that failed. Either that or something else is going on that I don't understand, but Roger is the sussy one here, not me.

LYNCH ROGER

[Aragorn]

It's nothing personal, it's just the logical line to follow that has not failed us so far. If you are innocent, then the next night cycle will give us the definitive mafia.

I'll wait to see if others players observed anything interesting in the night phase.

[Roy]

RIP Duck, you did us proud. Absolutely love that Null was shot again, two games in a row haha. First game I wanted to avenge his shooting but this game, I said that he was behaving uncharacteristically and he was on a lynch train on me and then Roger along with Prick.

Agent I knew was Town, you could work out his role from previous events - I would have liked to have seen an investigation of Roger or Weavo.

Onto who is the remaining Mafia then - since no one has contested Tibb's role claim, I'm happy he's town for now (although there is still the suspicious nature of how he voted Duck and then voted Roger along with Null and Prick).

Leaving Roger and Weavo. One is Mafia, one is the Trickster.

Whilst I do believe that Null and Prick could have turned on Roger for being a bad Mafia member, I think the most likely scenario is that he was just another town member for them to run a lynch train on. And Roger is the most likely to have used the Trickster ability on a day that was actually harmful for Town because he's so erratic (and generally a bad Town player), whereas Weavo is too considerate for that. So:

Lynch Weavo