Mafia 1988: MGSF Legends

[Aragorn]

Don't like this move by Annoying Prick (the character). Killed the chance of getting good info out of the night phase. If the idea is for the Mafia to burn their one disguise, I don't think it works that way (Annoying prick's ability overrides there and they can use it in the next phase).

With Prick being Mafia, it's a lot easier to draw lines in the sand.

Townies (confirmed)
Me
Tibbs
Starch

Townies (no role claims, but unlikely to be mafia)
Dirty Duck

Remaining:
Henry
Roy
Roger
Weavo
Agent

Prick has made a point to avoid Weavo & Null in his voting pattern, and Null was uncharacteristically non-committal and absent when Prick was getting heat. Similarly flopped around on the voting pattern in line with what Prick was pushing. I'm also not feeling very confident about Agent, but this is more down to gut sense than anything.

I'm okay putting Null or Weavo on the stand today.

EDIT: this isn't plagiarism I was typing as he posted.

[Dirty Duck]

Agent and Roy are innocent in my opinion, even without roleclaims.

[Roy]

Did Tibbs roleclaim Weavo/Repairman? I never saw it explicitly (didn't he just say 'ive helped out town'), please correct me if I'm wrong. But Duck did point it out at least that he has claimed that role and no one has contradicted.

I'm suspicious of Tibbs and Null for flipping, along with Prick when he was on the ropes, to Roger. Seemed like it was an intentional move/group effort from Mafia. Tibbs also voted Duck early in the day out of the blue when he was coming up with a plan to help Town. But without anyone contradicting his repairman role claim, I cant continue to put him as the most likely suspect so I'll put a pin in that for now.

Roger must be town given the switch to make him the lynch target. I tend to agree on Agent for a reason I shall not reveal.

So would also like to see what Null and Weavo have to say for themselves (after my almost lynching yesterday, I think people should get a chance to defend themselves before I put out a confirmed lynch!)

[Null]

I do think there’s a bit of hindsight involved in how my play is being interpreted now. I questioned the logic behind the Prick lynch because I genuinely didn’t think the Day 1 voting patterns were particularly convincing, and I still don’t think that was an unreasonable position at the time.

As for switching to Roger, that came from Tibbs suggesting him as an alternative, and I said at the time that he was the person I trusted most. Tibbs is pretty much confirmed Town and made the same move, so I’m not sure why that’s being treated as uniquely suspicious when I do it.

One other thing, the idea I’ve been “absent” is so loud, wrong, and uniquely irritating. I obviously got it wrong yesterday, but absent? I’ve been one of the most vocal players in the entire thread lol. I’ve literally posted more than you Faisal.

[Dirty Duck]

Let's wait for Null to post, yeah. We'll be waiting a long time though. He's barely participated for some reason. Must be busy.

[weavo]

I don't know why I'm suspect tbh? I don't think browsing the thread should be a crime if I'm honest, and I think Annoying Prick is too smart a player to just conveniently happen to accuse everyone except for his allies. It's equally possible one of the players he accused was mafia, and he was trying to change his vote to include them so they'd have a free run of it in the later stages by acting in such a way to suggest their innocence. In that case, my money would be on Roger or Roy, depending on which of those lynch attempts we think was genuine and which was a smokescreen.

[Dirty Duck]

I don't know why I'm suspect tbh? I don't think browsing the thread should be a crime if I'm honest, and I think Annoying Prick is too smart a player to just conveniently happen to accuse everyone except for his allies. It's equally possible one of the players he accused was mafia, and he was trying to change his vote to include them so they'd have a free run of it in the later stages by acting in such a way to suggest their innocence. In that case, my money would be on Roger or Roy, depending on which of those lynch attempts we think was genuine and which was a smokescreen.

You're not being accused for browsing the thread though, nor are you being accused based solely on who Prick voted. You're too smart a player to have used the Trickster ability last night, and by process of elimination that means you're one of two mafia roles.

Tibbs has roleclaimed, uncontested.
starschwar has roleclaimed, uncontested.
Aragorn is confirmed town.
Agent is town.
Roy is town.
I am town.

That leaves you, Null, Roger-all of whom voted for Roy along with Prick. I find it very hard to believe that 2 mafia members would jump on a lynch train for a fellow mafia member who hadn't done anything incriminating. The fact you're even still suggesting it could be Roy makes you more suspicious in my opinion. Whether you've left Null out because he's your mafia ally, or to make people think he's mafia if you die today and people look back at your posts tomorrow, is hard to tell.

[Aragorn]

One other thing, the idea I’ve been “absent” is so loud, wrong, and uniquely irritating. I obviously got it wrong yesterday, but absent? I’ve been one of the most vocal players in the entire thread lol. I’ve literally posted more than you Faisal.

It is not about overall activity level. I am saying you were very tiptoe-y on yesterday's cycle and uncharacteristically absent for that. UNCHARACTERISTICALLY.

[Roger]

I do have to say, Duck does take this game a lot serious than I expected. And I'm going to be real. I only chose Roy cause literally of us having names starting with the letter R. Nothing much to it. However, I do find it very suspicious that I got support for it rather quickly. Annoying Prick(member) and Null were pretty quick to vote against Roy. And then followed by Weavo. I find Null and Weavo very suspicious. And Annoying Prick(member) being Null(character), I just feel like Mafia probably were too eager to get a lynch train going. I strongly believe any other person other than Annoying Prick(member) that would've been chosen to be lynched would've been supported by Null and Weavo.

[Aragorn]

@bigboss88 can we get a confirmation on how trickster works in relation to other powers? if trickster was used, and the mafia masked someone - is that ability now burned or they can use it in the subsequent cycle?