MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Mr. Tibbs]

I mean, yeah I can't really explain it but he's claiming the same role as me and I have it. So I'm gonna vote for him.

As for focusing in on specific points, I'm just responding to points you've mentioned multiple times. Obviously I don't really have any way to prove anything, but if I'm going to be suspected I at least want to be clear about those points. I was not trying to deflect blame from BB88, I was just being ponderous lol

[starschwar]

Hmm.. Maybe I got the lynching wrong?  Didn't BB88 vote to lynch aragorn first on the first day? I could be misremembering. You know, account of all the death and backstabbing here and there. As well as the fact the most usefull ones died pretty early on.

He did on the first day but then every other day he vehemently defended him. His entire attack on me was based on the supposed message that Aragorn received confirming his role and the idea that Aragorn was confirmed town by virtue of being The Final Girl.

@Roy @Mr. Tibbs @starschwar

Role claim or be seen as potential mafia. The Virgin has role claimed so I don't really see a reason that any town wouldn't at this point.

I was shy about it, but fine.




That's my role. Not getting killed by Ghostface.

[Annoying Prick]

I was shy about it, but fine.



That's my role.  Not getting killed by Ghostface.

Did you see that Roger claimed the same role? What do you say to that? What do you think of Roy and Tibbs claiming the same role?

[starschwar]

I was shy about it, but fine.



That's my role.  Not getting killed by Ghostface.

Did you see that Roger claimed the same role? What do you say to that? What do you think of Roy and Tibbs claiming the same role?

Well, I haven't been killed yet and neither have they.  It's a very plausible role for anyone alive to claim.  It's also a role that doesn't let me get any useful information - I've had absolutely no leads the whole game because of it.  If someone else got intel while also claiming the role, well, both of those things can't be true.

[Annoying Prick]

Feel like we shouldn't really need to rely on intel or leads from night actions at this point. Enough has happened for us to make some inferences just from how people have played. You're playing it very safe.

I've checked Roger's post history but you both seem pretty suspicious at different points for different reasons.

Lynch Mr. Tibbs.

I checked back even further and Roy was suspecting BB88 and Aragorn as early as page 19. There's just no way he's mafia. It makes no sense for him to draw suspicion to his fellow mafia and claiming Aragorn's confirmed innocence was all part of BB88's plan so it suggests that Roy was never involved in that plan.

EDIT: Oh, sorry Star, you mean to say that we should check to see if Roger has implied he got information from night actions that The Virgin couldn't have got? That's reasonable but I can't see anything like that from Roger.

EDIT EDIT: I'm going to go to bed now. Mr. Tibbs is the best vote to kill a mafia in this day phase in my opinion. If Tibbs is lynched and turns out to be mafia and the day phase is over before I wake up then I want the town to know that I plan to use my night time ability on Roger. If I die or anyone else dies during the night then we know that Star is mafia.

[Aragorn]

This insistence that I’m Mafia atp is ridiculous. THE GOSSIP LIVES. ONE OF THESE FUCKERS IS LYING.

I’m on my phone because MGSF has been timing out for me all day, but I will tell you verbatim (not SCs) what the gossip has been telling me. He was delivering BB88s words, which led me to believe that he is the gossip.

I’ll catch up with the remaining accusations, but I sincerely doubt we have more than one unroled townie.

[Mr. Tibbs]

We already covered all that lol. You and prick are basically confirmed town as far as anyone is concerned. Currently there's a roleclaim shootout with Roy claiming to have no role and me having no role. And then both Roger ans Starschwar claiming to be the Virgin.

I'm voting to lynch Roy because he's claiming my role. Prick is voting to lynch me because he believes Roy over me because he thinks I tried to save bb88 ( I didn't)

So. Shit is a little hectic at the moment lol

[Dirty Duck]

1 vote for Roy. 1 vote for Mr. Tibbs.

4 left to vote.

[Roger]

Before Roy joined, we had 12 players. 12 roles. Roy was a late addition due to whatever reason. I am very positive Duck had the roles already assigned via whatever method he used. So IF there is a player without a role, it only make sense for it to be Roy. Now, if we assumed duck decided to not give 2 people roles that is fine. Because even without a role, you can still be an accomplice. Any accomplice can drop the costume on anyone. I believe I was targeted last night and was intended to be framed.  I find it funny how no one wants to claim THE GOSSIP role.

MR TIBBS AND STAR ARE THE MAFIA.

LYNCH MR TIBBS

[Mr. Tibbs]

Ah so you are the other one. I assumed it was Stars.

Hopefully if I get killed gorn and prick can stay alive and lynch Roy and Roger

Also I dislike being meta about this, but Duck did clarify that he had already sent Roy a role but then had shuffled assuming he was absent. So there's absolutely nothing confirming he is the no role player. Which in my mind more or less confirms that you two are working together as mafia