MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Annoying Prick]

I did suggest that the least active users could most likely be the other mafia members. BB88 wanted Aragorn gone, would it make sense for Mafia to kill their own? Weavo confirmed Annoying Prick role. Aragorn role has been confirmed. As far as I'm aware, the most suspicious are the most inactive, due to these long nights. So we have two possibilities. Annoying prick happened to block Aragorn the same night I was chosen to be killed. Unfortunately, I cannot be killed. I think Star, Roy and Mr Tibbs are the most suspicious.

When and where did BB88 "want Aragorn gone?" He constantly defended him against even the slightest indication of Aragorn being mafia. If there is an argument for Aragorn being town it's that BB88 used him as his alibi and needed him alive for that reason, but everything BB88 said beyond the first day would suggest he and Aragorn were aligned.

So you're The Virgin. I guess as long as nobody else claims that role then you're in the clear. I really think we should just all role claim at this point.

[Roger]

Hmm.. Maybe I got the lynching wrong? Didn't BB88 vote to lynch aragorn first on the first day? I could be misremembering. You know, account of all the death and backstabbing here and there. As well as the fact the most usefull ones died pretty early on.

[Annoying Prick]

Hmm.. Maybe I got the lynching wrong?  Didn't BB88 vote to lynch aragorn first on the first day? I could be misremembering. You know, account of all the death and backstabbing here and there. As well as the fact the most usefull ones died pretty early on.

He did on the first day but then every other day he vehemently defended him. His entire attack on me was based on the supposed message that Aragorn received confirming his role and the idea that Aragorn was confirmed town by virtue of being The Final Girl.

@Roy @Mr. Tibbs @starschwar

Role claim or be seen as potential mafia. The Virgin has role claimed so I don't really see a reason that any town wouldn't at this point.

[Roger]

Hmm. I don't think that seems remotely suspicious. But I do find it interesting how after night 1 he changed his stance. Maybe I'm reading too much into it. At the moment I do think the least active members are due for suspicion. And I seem to be the only one out of the recent inactive members to want this idea.

Either we choose one, and if anyone doesn't follow suit then its clearly mafia. But if we choose 1, and the other 2 are full on board for it. We lose. We are literally playing huge gamble on this haha.

[Mr. Tibbs]

I take slight issue being branded "inactive" tbh. I've been here every day, just haven't been posting on Aragorn levels but that's normal lol.

That said, with someone roleclaiming the virign I guess there's no point in anyone else holding back. Assuming they're telling the truth. Which again is a risky assumption at this point. We're going to end up with someone double claiming and the math not adding up because two of the remaining roles are confirmed mafia at this point since we know the gossip was working with bb88.

I don't really have anything to risk, since I'm the odd player out without a role. I thought it would be better for the virgin to not roleclaim but since the cats out of the bag we might as well give it a shot.

My bet is on Roy for trying to get Aragorn lynched even after he's basically 85% confirmed townie or Roger is lying about being the virgin. As for stars I have no idea he's barely posted so could be anyone so that's kind of a day 1 situation.

[Annoying Prick]

I take slight issue being branded "inactive" tbh. I've been here every day, just haven't been posting on Aragorn levels but that's normal lol.

That said, with someone roleclaiming the virign I guess there's no point in anyone else holding back. Assuming they're telling the truth. Which again is a risky assumption at this point. We're going to end up with someone double claiming and the math not adding up because two of the remaining roles are confirmed mafia at this point since we know the gossip was working with bb88.

Sorry, we'll say "less active." Not posting essays like BB88 and I were for a bit.

I don't really understand how it's anymore risky than just lynching someone with the evidence we have so far. It will be easier to make a choice with people claiming roles against each other, not harder. I guess it means that if we lynch the wrong person during this day phase then we've lost the chance to have a potentially kill-free night later but I think we're at a point where we should be able to get a mafia. If four people claim the same role then we basically have a 50% chance to get one and in reality it won't be based on total guess work, we can judge their claim.

Although I'm definitely more nervous now haha.

[Mr. Tibbs]

I mean it's not really risky anymore. My thinking is once the roles are known the mafia has a much easier time getting a confirmed night kill. An accidental target on the virgin could be what saves the game but I agree overall it's kind of even odds probably. At this point the only people I think are safely town is you, gorny, and myself. Which I think is going to be what everyone else says too but yeah. It is what it is. At a certain point every mafia game has to end up like this:

[Roy]

I take slight issue being branded "inactive" tbh. I've been here every day, just haven't been posting on Aragorn levels but that's normal lol.

That said, with someone roleclaiming the virign I guess there's no point in anyone else holding back. Assuming they're telling the truth. Which again is a risky assumption at this point. We're going to end up with someone double claiming and the math not adding up because two of the remaining roles are confirmed mafia at this point since we know the gossip was working with bb88.

I don't really have anything to risk, since I'm the odd player out without a role. I thought it would be better for the virgin to not roleclaim but since  the cats out of the bag we might as well give it a shot.

My bet is on Roy for trying to get Aragorn lynched even after he's basically 85% confirmed townie or Roger is lying about being the virgin. As for stars I have no idea he's barely posted so could be anyone so that's kind of a day 1 situation.

Could you clarify what you mean when you say you don't have a role?

[Mr. Tibbs]

Just a townie who can't do anything at night

[Roy]

I am a townie who has no role. There's 13 players and 12 roles so unless Duck tells us otherwise, only one person can not have a role. And since thats me, then you are very likely the killer.