MGF Mafia 2.0: The Matrix

[Dirty Duck]

Current Votes:
Aragorn: 4
No lynch: 2

[black king]

I'll No Lynch. 

[Agent]

I'd love to lynch aragorn but if we're wrong again we have to lynch correctly tomorrow or lose. I'd rather go into day 4 with more info and more options.

[Aragorn]

I admit, I'm not solid on any course of action, but I'm really at a loss for anything else. I was wrong about the meaning of "Contact" and it's entirely possible Aragorn was as well. I don't think we have anything else even resembling evidence now. I'm aware that my own screwup could just as easily be interpreted as suspicious, and wouldn't blame anybody for treating my actions as such. But I'm certainly not going to vote for myself, that'd be -really- nonsensical.

Obviously I’m not saying lynch yourself, I’m just saying it’s a titanic leap in logic to lynch me over what was a very sensible decision last night. We bought ourselves an extra day, it is pointless to squander it by lynching me.

[Jassassino]

I admit, I'm not solid on any course of action, but I'm really at a loss for anything else. I was wrong about the meaning of "Contact" and it's entirely possible Aragorn was as well. I don't think we have anything else even resembling evidence now. I'm aware that my own screwup could just as easily be interpreted as suspicious, and wouldn't blame anybody for treating my actions as such. But I'm certainly not going to vote for myself, that'd be -really- nonsensical.

Obviously I’m not saying lynch yourself, I’m just saying it’s a titanic leap in logic to lynch me over what was a very sensible decision last night. We bought ourselves an extra day, it is pointless to squander it by lynching me.

It was sensible exactly until it wasn't, and tbh, there was more than plenty of time and opportunity to see that Annoying Prick was telling the truth - obviously the continuing lynch votes to him come mainly as a result of me being hit with "unable to speak" the moment he soft confirmed 3 players (including himself) of being Town, but your relation to it all and how close you were is too much to deny (IMO)

[Aragorn]

My “relationship” to all this is you started a random lynch train on me, reverted back after on Annoying Prick since he bandwagoned (so did BK btw, I know he’s on my side now but I’m not discounting the fact that he’s been moving suspect all game) and then you were silenced right after. I only casted my vote after Starch hard confirmed that there was bullshit going on; now mind you it turned out to not be the case - but once again my line of thinking was completely normal & reasonable.

Some might think It’s too late in the game to no lynch I suppose; but killing me plays right into the Mafia’s hands. Since we got ourselves an extra day with the nullification of yesterday, the wisest course of action is to No Lynch in my eyes and do something more concrete.

[black king]

and we have BK in the mix who’s been skirting the whole game

(so did BK btw, I know he’s on my side now but I’m not discounting the fact that he’s been moving suspect all game) 

In my defense, this is my first game as a townie since 2018. 

Also, for us being on the same side you certainly seem to want to throw shade at me.

[Aragorn]

I’m just being objective - but either way the idea isn’t to lynch you right now. We just can’t afford another mistake.

[Jassassino]

I'm 90% sure of BK being town.

There's other more blatant players sidelining the game, saying neutral statements to retain any level of innocence in this game, so to point to BK is weird. His only truly strange interaction, which would cast any suspicion on him IMO, is his misremembering of an order of lynch votes on Day 2. But that's honestly nothing.

The problem is that you instantly called to say that StarSchwar's comment confirmed that Prick must be Mafia. Nearly identical timing to when I was hit with silence.

No Lynch is a waste, we need a Mafia kill or else we'll be prone. Unless you can vehemently claim and confirm you're Town in any way, you seem like the best option IMO.

[Dirty Duck]

Current Votes:
Aragorn: 4
No lynch: 4

Everyone has voted now, I'll end the day phase in a couple of hours. Unless a player gets more than 50% of votes it will end in a no lynch.