What are you playing?

[NateDog]

It's weird though, it's not like I didn't like them but they just didn't like capture my imagination the same way Final Fantasy or Mass Effect did, for whatever reason.

Maybe it's too open for you? I had that issue with some RPGs and it was definitely a factor here with TW3. I like an open world but sometimes it can be a bit too daunting to look at especially if it's so open early on. TW2 I found was a bit more contained and I liked that.