Blood on the Clocktower

[Agent]

Since Agent's accusation of Aragorn rests on the assumption I was the Minion 

It doesn't, read my post again, I outlined every logical possibility, even the most unlikely ones for anyone still unconvinced.

I was confused by "the most likely" following the scenario where I am the Minion. So you believe that Aragorn is the Imp and Duck is the Minion or Null is the Imp and Duck is the Minion.

Yeah I meant that number 1 was the most likely scenario, and even if you were the minion (I know you're not), Aragorn is still most likely to be the demon. Null could be the demon too, on paper, but i'm not covering all the other sussy posting from Aragorn/Duck because we have enough factual info to make the call at this point. 

I have soft role claimed and Star knows this. Unsure why he's still reluctant to vote.

The thing is you only soft role claimed after he had already said that either you or Aragorn are confirmed town. You didn't actually provide any new information, potentially you just took the opportunity he gave you to lie. On top of that you haven't actually said the role so Star doesn't actually know that you even know what role he imagines you to be. I think the smart thing to do would be for you to role claim first and then for him to confirm or deny your stated role after that. If you are reluctant to do that then I would ask why.

The info I gave could only refer to one role. I've already reposted it once. You have the right thought process though.