MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Roger]

I'm gonna level with you friendo, there has been a lot of information going around here. The fact Stars claimed my role secured my mind. If Roy was added in as an accomplice last minute, which I did consider. But I don't think Duck would've thrown a wrench like that... Unless he would? Too bad, I made my decision. I need some pretty strong convincing as to why you 2, Mr Tibs and Stars seem to be double roles.

And just because Roy and I would have the most killer name combo, R&R, does not make us out to be the killers. Like I said, we are at a gamble now. And I am gambling that Mr Tibbs and Stars are mafia.

[Roy]

I'm not 100% sure that there can't be two unassigned roles, but Mr Tibbs pushing this as a way to lynch me convinces me that he's our best shot at getting a mafia right now

Lynch Mr Tibbs

[Mr. Tibbs]

The only way there could be more than one no-role would be if a role isn't even being used. So either Aragorn has pulled off the greatest caper in history and fabricated a gossip or you're the gossip or killer and are claiming my role

[Roy]

The only way there could be more than one no-role would be if a role isn't even being used. So either Aragorn has pulled off the greatest caper in history and fabricated a gossip or you're the gossip or killer and are claiming my role

Unless we get a rule clarification that there can be unused roles or that someone can have multiple roles  - which I feel like Duck would leave ambiguous like our last question.

EDIT: or whether multiple people can have the same role (meaning Roger and Star could be telling the truth)

[Roger]

If there are multiple roles, personally, I think that sucks >:C

[Annoying Prick]

Roger's vote has thrown me off a bit. I thought he was the most likely to be mafia. But I'm still voting Tibbs. My reasoning entirely hinges on Roy being willing to vote to lynch BB88 and casting suspicion at him and Aragorn as early as page 19. This suggests he was never working with BB88 and was willing to lynch mafia.

If Tibbs dies and is mafia I will now use my night power on Star during the night phase. If anyone dies then we know Roger is mafia.

[Dirty Duck]

3 votes for Mr. Tibbs. 1 vote for Roy.

2 left to vote.

[Dirty Duck]

If there are multiple roles, personally, I think that sucks >:C

Every player has a maximum of one role.

[Aragorn]

My only problem with the Tibbs theory is whoever the gossip is, is very passive since they let BB run the game for them. Just not Tibb’s usual MO.

[Annoying Prick]

My only problem with the Tibbs theory is whoever the gossip is, is very passive since they let BB run the game for them. Just not Tibb’s usual MO.

Well Star could be The Gossip and Tibbs could be The Killer. Tibbs also said he was busy during the day phase that BB88 was lynched so that could have been true. He was quite active at the end of the day phase 

At the end of the day it's Roy or Tibbs and Tibbs just seems far more likely. To me it isn't rocket scientist. Do we think that the guy who was trying to lynch the confirmed mafia and was arguing against the mafia's plan was on their side or the guy who wasn't doing those things?