MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Jassassino]

Yeah lynching someone is always good. We need to satiate the blood lust of the angry peasants and lay down their torches and pitchforks.

I personally think Agent is suspicious because it's been one day and he hasn't given us a precise probability and likelihood of everybody's exact allegiances, roles and last time they took a dump. Very out of character, if I do say so myself.

[weavo]

Yeah those inactive players are hella suspicious, wouldn't be me though...

Statistically isn't it better for town not to get someone on day 1 though, if that's an option? Since chances are it'd just be doing the killer's work for them.

[bigboss88]

Ok, so we have three inactives right now: Wayno, star and Aragorn. I don’t think all are mafia, but I do think one of them (at least) is mafia.

@Dirty Duck Can we have a clarification of how many mafia members are there?

[Dirty Duck]

@Dirty Duck Can we have a clarification of how many mafia members are there?

[bigboss88]

Well, in that case, I’ll have to say 3-4. Leaning towards 3 for the moment as it makes the most sense. So either:-
a. We have a whole group of inactive mafia members. (Giving it only 1% tbh)
b. Two inactive mafia members. (More probable but gonna give it only 10% and that a pretty generous rate. I’m gonna give it 9% just to keep the scale steady)
c. One inactive mafia member. (Most probable. Usually one mafia keeps a very low profile as a backup plan. So I’m giving it 75%. My money is on Aragorn so far for the reasons I specified before)
d. All mafia members are active. (Second probable option but I seriously doubt it. The remaining 15% goes here)

I’m this close to casting my vote, but I’m giving Aragorn more time just in case life got in the way.

[Annoying Prick]

There isn't really anything to go on for the first day. I think lynching is a good idea because even if we kill a town it gives some clues. Maybe that's actually non-optimal but it makes sense to me.

[Aragorn]

WAIT!

I’m not inconsistent I literally misread the game start time. That is on me, I’ll catch up and give my input in a minute.

[Aragorn]

Fuck off mate 2 pages of nothing burger I got excited for a second.

Anyways: i'm pro lynching on the first day. My defense for not lynching me is the only reasonable thing anyone can say at this stage of the game: I am innocent, but in general I do think it's better to start eliminating rather than letting a day pass with nothing to go off for the next day.

[bigboss88]

WAIT!

I’m not inconsistent I literally misread the game start time. That is on me, I’ll catch up and give my input in a minute.

Knowing you, you’d be the first to post in every mafia game I hosted back then 🤣 but I have to consider the fact you’re telling the truth. Being active from now on might clear your name. Although it would be one of the biggest plot twist if the killer’s is hidden in plain sight in the rules. As a matter of fact, it fits the Scream theme chosen for this game. 🤣

[Dirty Duck]

@Null
@Wayno
@Jassassino
@Roger
@black king
@starschwar
@Agent
@Annoying Prick
@Mr. Tibbs
@Aragorn
@bigboss88
@weavo

Please like this post if you got a notification you were tagged.