MGF Mafia 2.0: The Matrix

[Null]

I mean, again. One of you is clearly lying. This could be Agent and ‘Gorn coordinating pressure onto BK. But I’m slightly more suspicious of BK right now.

There’s a clear contradiction. I’m not sure how else to parse it.

[starschwar]

The way I see it - silencing people is not a useful tactic for Town.  We need more info, not less. Especially when the people we had who were most capable of gaining actionable intel were the first casualties.  But a lot of behavior isn't adding up.  Lots of plausible deniability all around.


Agent did not answer my question about Aragorn's reference, and became defensive when Null asked about it too.  Agent was Jas's secondary suspect.  BK's silencing doesn't make any sense to me, either.  The lack of lynch votes for Aragorn could be an attempt to add plausible deniability. 


I am taking back my vote.  I'm going to check this thread again later this evening and read everybody's replies and render my final decision then.

[Null]

I’m also taking back my vote for now. Let’s see how this plays out.

[black king]

I mean, again. One of you is clearly lying. This could be Agent and ‘Gorn coordinating pressure onto BK. But I’m slightly more suspicious of BK right now.

There’s a clear contradiction. I’m not sure how else to parse it.

One is lying and it's Agent. I'd hoped me admitting to my role and blocking you twice would've cleared me in your mind since the time of the blocks can't be faked. 

[Agent]

I'm curious to see what st3ve has to say. If nothing else comes up you'll just have to go with your gut instinct. Even if you make the right call, I am likely to die in the night and honestly i'm not 100% on who the other one is.

[Null]

St3ve’s apparently stuck in the largest traffic jam of all time

[black king]

St3ve’s apparently stuck in the largest traffic jam of all time

Caused by a crudely drawn truck driver.

[starschwar]

I never want to pry into anyone's real life, but the traffic thing is weird unless Steve's job/family/etc requires a lot of transit.  All in all... I'm still not convinced of any course of action.  The best thing we have to go on is still Jas.  The silencing and blocking and all that, it seems suspicious to me, but we're all operating in some amount of shadow here.  One false move and it's over for Town.  And the only surefire way to fail is to not lynch anybody. 

King's actions don't make too much sense to me.  But Agent's alibi and apparent attempts at evasion/deflection stand out as more suspicious.  Coupled with Jas - one of the only people who could have actually gotten us an answer - suspecting him, I fear that's all we have to go on right now.  



With three members of Town gone, our odds of being right, even for the wrong reasoning have improved.  I hate that we have to make this kind of choice, but I have to make the best of Bits and Pieces.

Vote: Lynch Agent.

[Null]

If that’s where the momentum is going, I’ll follow. I’m pretty sure Star is town, although they could be playing one of the best mafia turns ever with BK as a partner.

The key conflict remains the night 2 mechanic. Either Agent or BK need to fall tonight. This is a gamble but I’m comfortable given where the chips currently are.

Lynch Agent. 

[Aragorn]

I mean, again. One of you is clearly lying. This could be Agent and ‘Gorn coordinating pressure onto BK. But I’m slightly more suspicious of BK right now.

There’s a clear contradiction. I’m not sure how else to parse it.

One is lying and it's Agent. I'd hoped me admitting to my role and blocking you twice would've cleared me in your mind since the time of the blocks can't be faked. 

Then can Null confirm that he was indeed blocked twice? If I’m understanding Duck right then he should be notified.