MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Roger]

I made my choice. And I am mainly on gut feeling. IIRC Roy had also considered the less active members of the game. Neither Mr Tibbs or Star considered that as an option. I don't know, a mafia member pretending to rat out their own seems a bit of a huge gamble to me. I stand by my choice.

[Annoying Prick]

I made my choice. And I am mainly on gut feeling. IIRC Roy had also considered the less active members of the game. Neither Mr Tibbs or Star considered that as an option. I don't know, a mafia member pretending to rat out their own seems a bit of a huge gamble to me. I stand by my choice.

I just don't see the incentive in pretending to rat out their own at such an early point of the game. Roy was saying these things as early as page 19, well before anyone had lynch voted BB88. He was sowing suspicion of the mafia and their plan really early on.

Also you're wrong about Tibbs. On the day that BB88 was lynched he was trying to get us to consider the less active members. See what Tibbs was saying on page 25. He even seems to implicate Stars potentially around that point (alongside you and Roy). Roy on the other hand was basically never suspicious about the less active players, he was always focused on BB88 and Aragorn. He also implicated you and BK around page 12. Not sure if that changes how you vote.

[Roger]

Well it doesn't. Star is claiming my role. So he is Mafia. If Aragorn could come in and relay the messages he's gotten and it proves mr tibbs innocent in any way, I'll back off. I am The Virgin. I mean there could be a possibility that Roy got added in late and became the other accomplice but I don't think it'll be that simple. And if it is that simple and I chose Mr Tibbs and I was wrong well that is on me.

[Dirty Duck]

I mean there could be a possibility that Roy got added in late and became the other accomplice but I don't think it'll be that simple.

Overall player number affects how many mafia players there are so you are right that this is one thing that could have happened with Roy's addition to the game. Roy should not be seen as guaranteed town based purely on him being a last minute addition.

[Roger]

Damn. My whole idea was based on it wouldn't be that simple.

Also I just thought of something. If the killer had tried to kill me, I feel like Duck would've done a description of my narrow escape. Instead, night just passed. I feel like the mafia will have to kill at this point. Or maybe it'll just tell the killer, no dice bud. I still think that it is weird that there was no kill last night. And from my understanding the accomplices themselves can't kill only the killer. @Annoying Prick Did you smoke a joint with anyone last night?

EDIT:I gotta go to work now. So I won't be able to see anything till much later. I am choosing to unlynch mr tibbs for now but Star is still seriously suspicios to me.

[Dirty Duck]

Damn. My whole idea was based on it wouldn't be that simple.

Maybe it isn't, but the late addition doesn't guarantee Roy's allegiance to town or mafia. It could have gone either way.

[starschwar]

A.P.  is convinced I'm not what I say, so in the interest of my own survival (and revealing the true culprit), I have no other choice.  Nothing personal.

Lynch Roy

[Annoying Prick]

Damn. My whole idea was based on it wouldn't be that simple.

Also I just thought of something. If the killer had tried to kill me, I feel like Duck would've done a description of my narrow escape. Instead, night just passed. I feel like the mafia will have to kill at this point. Or maybe it'll just tell the killer, no dice bud. I still think that it is weird that there was no kill last night. And from my understanding the accomplices themselves can't kill only the killer. @Annoying Prick Did you smoke a joint with anyone last night?

EDIT:I gotta go to work now. So I won't be able to see anything till much later. I am choosing to unlynch mr tibbs for now but Star is still seriously suspicios to me.

I've already said, I shared my joint with Aragorn. It's weird that he doesn't know this somehow as Weavo did but I think it might just be because he didn't attempt a blockable action.

I have to say something now that I learned in a way that is illegitimate and contrary to the rules of the game but that is weird to be coy about. I'll say it while remaining compliant with the rule that stuff learned outside of the forum cannot have screenshot evidence posted of it, so you'll have to just trust me. I know for a fact that the reason nobody died is because BB88 used the mafia killing power during the day. I also know that mafia wanted to target me but weren't able to for this reason. So I know there is nothing to read into my weed power.

Honestly I am surprised how indifferent you guys are all being to the evidence around BB88 and the lynch voting behaviour of Roy and Tibbs. After the first day everyone was acting like there were deep insights to be gained from theorising about random lynch trains done with zero evidence. We now have a confirmed mafia who was lynched and clearly had some kind of thought out plan that involved the direct cooperation of at least one other mafia player and everyone is acting like it's of no interest that Roy didn't seem to be a participant in the plan at all and was trying to get BB88 lynched from the start of that day phase. If Roy was mafia he would have been siding with BB88 against me and saying that Aragorn was confirmed town and that BB88 was likely town as a result, not sowing distrust of BB88 and his plan by calling both him and Aragorn into question as town players. I see no other way to read it and I can't change my vote, it's way stronger evidence than literally anything else anyone has brought up.

[Aragorn]

I’ll vote Tibbs. It is ultimately all we’ve got.

[Roger]

Then I'm back on the saddle,

LYNCH THE TIBBS