MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Roy]

Mafia is either BB88 + Aragorn or Roger + starschwar as the most inactive two haha.

I think the BB88 and Aragorn duo need to be lynched even if they are town for how much they've harmed the town team. So

Lynch BB88

[bigboss88]

Outing yourself as sheriff/deputy is putting a target on your back for potentially little gain, given the role is made less useful by the mask hiding mechanic.

Anyway, as the deputy I can confirm that Agent did not have the mask on night 2. Last night I got stoned and couldn't do anything, but obviously I wasn't going to look at Agent as per BB88's request given I'd already checked the night before. I intended to look at a random low-volume player on the off chance I got lucky, but that's not relevant. Whoever the stoner is can confirm I'm telling the truth.

This is why I'm so hung up on BB88's 'certainty' that if BK wasn't mafia, Agent would be. If BB88 is mafia, he'd have known that BK wouldn't be mafia and that Agent WOULD have the mask last night, given they presumably planted it (or colluded with the other killer to do so). BB88 was also a huge part of the mob against BK while trying to pin responsibility for that on Agent, to the point that BK switched his vote FROM Agent TO BB88 while being targetted, just as BB88 was trying to push responsibility onto Agent in the hope he'd be lynched next once BK he was confirmed town.

As far as I am concerned, Agent is confirmed town and BK probably was too. As a result, I can't think of any plausible scenario for Agent's death that ISN'T the mafia accidentally killing him as a result of his Jock power after trying to frame him (lol). It doesn't make sense for mafia to kill one of their own. It doesn't make sense for them to try to kill the final girl. It doesn't make sense for them to intentionally kill the person they're trying to frame at night, when obviously it's better to do it during the day as mafia almost certainly wouldn't kill one of their own for no reason.

So who was trying to frame Agent? Well, you'd have to assume it's the person who said "If bk is town, Agent is 100% mafia. As simple as that."

Namely, BB88.

I'm also fairly suspicious of his claims that he is 'confirmed town' for reasons I don't follow, or his 'mountains of evidence' that Annoying Prick is mafia, which seems fairly confused/insubstantial (though maybe their dialogue is two mafia trying to muddy the waters, who knows). It's not impossible this is a coincidence or a misunderstanding on my part, so BB88 you have the floor if you want to help me understand. But until then...

LYNCH BIGBOSS88

If anybody is deputy, now is the time to share. As this how mafia is gonna win. We’re 5 vs 2 or 5 vs 3. If they are 3, then Agent, Prick and Weavo win. This town hasn’t been active I felt I was playing alone. If I die and turn out to be town, I’m not playing if this inactivity is a case of just town being inactive.

[Dirty Duck]

After the accusation everyone's gaze was fixed on the accused. He attempted to respond as best he could but eventually realised his words weren't getting through. He reached inside his jacket and pulled out a flash of gleaming steel-nobody had time to react. He lunged forward and stabbed a knife into the neck of the man who'd pointed the finger at him, who coughed and spluttered blood onto his attacker's face. The stabber let go of the weapon and let it fall to the ground alongside the recently deceased man on the end of it...

Woodsboro clearly had a penchant for the public execution of its law enforcement. (waow based)

ALIVE (7):
Roger
starschwar
Annoying Prick
Mr. Tibbs
Aragorn
Bigboss88
Roy
DEAD:
Jassassino (The Reporter) Night Killed Night 1
Null (The Sheriff) Shot Day Two
Wayno (The Prime Suspect) Night Killed Night 2
black king (The Horror Nerd) Lynched Day 3
Agent (The Jock) Night Killed Night 3 Ghostface Costume
weavo (The Deputy) Day Killed Day 4

DAY FOUR CONTINUES

2 votes for bigboss88. 1 vote for Annoying Prick.

4 left to vote.

[bigboss88]

I guess that clears me here. Aragorn knows my role and I can’t kill at day or night. I claim the gossip and @Aragorn can confirm me.

What were you @Annoying Prick thinking when you killed Weavo this early. 🤣🤣🤣

[Annoying Prick]

I guess that clears me here. Aragorn knows my role and I can’t kill at day or night. I claim the gossip and @Aragorn can confirm me.

What were you @Annoying Prick thinking when you killed Weavo this early. 🤣🤣🤣

I didn't kill weavo. Weavo already role claimed deputy (were you not paying attention? He said he was the deputy ages ago) and said he was visited by the Stoner. I role claimed the Stoner and nobody else role claimed it. So I am the Stoner unless someone else says otherwise.

The Stoner cannot kill people during the day.

Important part of weavo role claiming the deputy earlier is that he said he had checked Agent on night two and Agent did not have the costume, implying Agent has been framed.

I would have had literally zero incentive to kill weavo anyway, he was on my side.

[bigboss88]

I guess that clears me here. Aragorn knows my role and I can’t kill at day or night. I claim the gossip and @Aragorn can confirm me.

What were you @Annoying Prick thinking when you killed Weavo this early. 🤣🤣🤣

I didn't kill weavo. Weavo already role claimed deputy (were you not paying attention? He said he was the deputy ages ago) and said he was visited by the Stoner. I role claimed the Stoner and nobody else role claimed it. So I am the Stoner unless someone else says otherwise.

The Stoner cannot kill people during the day.

Important part of weavo role claiming the deputy earlier is that he said he had checked Agent on night two and Agent did not have the costume, implying Agent has been framed.

I would have had literally zero incentive to kill weavo anyway, he was on my side.

Unlynch Annoying Prick

Something doesn’t add up. Annoying Prick is confirmed Stoner because Weavo was role blocked last night. Weavo is confirmed deputy now so his statement about being role blocked. Right now, I don’t know what to believe.

I’ll let someone else take the lead.

[Annoying Prick]

Unlynch Annoying Prick
Something doesn’t add up. Annoying Prick is confirmed Stoner because Weavo was role blocked last night. Weavo is confirmed deputy now so his statement about being role blocked. Right now, I don’t know what to believe.

I’ll let someone else take the lead.

Wow, I'm surprised to see this. I was really starting to think you were an accomplice but now I'm open to the idea that you are a town and we were just at each other's throats for no good reason.

Unlynch BB88

Of the alive players here are the roles that are likely confirmed:

Annoying Prick - Stoner, likely confirmed because weavo confirmed he was visited by the Stoner during night three and I role claimed and have not been challenged
Aragorn - The Final Girl, likely confirmed because he shot Null during day one and only The Final Girl has this power
BB88 - The Gossip, likely confirmed as he messaged Aragorn/The Final Girl who has confirmed this happened

Now per the written rules we could all still be accomplices and there is no real reason to think otherwise. However, that seems like a bad assumption to work off of for the following reason.

Weavo said that he had checked Agent on night two and he didn't have the ghost costume. When Agent died during night three he showed up as having the ghost costume. This probably means that Agent was framed and was not mafia. This means that there are at least two mafia still in play. One of them is The Killer and the other one is whichever role is capable of stabbing people during the day phase. Assuming that none of us have the ability to do that, and we don't appear to, then that means we are either a second accomplice to the killer or all town.

So assuming this is all true the best person to vote for would be one of these four:

Mr. Tibbs
Roger
starschwar
Roy

So as long as everything written above is correct then that means there is at least a 50% chance of us getting a mafia if we vote for one of these at random.

One thing unanswered is what the role is that managed to stab weavo to death. None of the roles seem to have a daytime stabbing power. What I do notice is this role:

" The Class Clown
A practical joker full of surprises.
Can perform a night action during the day. They will not be able to perform that action the following night."

What does this mean? Does this mean it's a kind of wildcard role that can use the night powers of any other role during the day? If so that's probably the role that killed weavo and they used The Killer's stabbing power during the day. This means The Class Clown is an accomplice.

@Dirty Duck Can you clarify how this role works? Have I described it accurately? Also can you confirm whether or not The Final Girl's gun power would count as a "night action?"

EDIT: I tried to check people's activity on their profiles to gauge who might have seen the chat and sent that instruction to Duck. At the time of writing this Roger was last on six hours ago and Mr Tibbs was last on 7 hours ago. Starschwar and Roy both have their last visit hidden. So I think there's no leads there, any of them could have done it since nobody has been confirmed totally inactive for days at a time or anything and they all could have had the opportunity to read weavo role claim Deputy, besides maybe Starschwar since we can't know when he last visited the forum and he hasn't posted. Based on this information I would avoid voting Starschwar for now.

[Dirty Duck]

After the accusation everyone's gaze was fixed on the accused. He attempted to respond as best he could but eventually realised his words weren't getting through. He reached inside his jacket and pulled out a flash of gleaming steel-nobody had time to react. He lunged forward and stabbed a knife into the neck of the man who'd pointed the finger at him, who coughed and spluttered blood onto his attacker's face. The stabber let go of the weapon and let it fall to the ground alongside the recently deceased man on the end of it...

Woodsboro clearly had a penchant for the public execution of its law enforcement. (waow based)

TRANSLATION: bigboss88 killed weavo in front of you all and you saw it happen just now in front of your very eyes for real no take backsies

[Annoying Prick]

Oh right I see. I did wonder since it said "his accussor" but I wasn't sure how much we should read into the themeing of the announcements haha.

In that case: Lynch Bigboss88

I guess he's The Class Clown and he messaged Aragorn using the messaging power of The Gossip? It's weird though because Aragorn said he was messaged at night which shouldn't be possible if I am reading the roles correctly.

[Dirty Duck]

Oh right I see. I did wonder since it said "his accusor" but I wasn't sure how much we should read into the themeing of the announcements haha.

The prose is written to reflect what is actually going on, and sometimes is the only clue to stranger deaths or happenings. Mechanically you are all meant to know explicitly what happened just now so I thought I'd clarify lol