MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[bigboss88]

I pointed to that in my edit. It was the thing that stopped me from considering to lynch you on day 3. It was the only thing you could do after being cornered, but now trying to take us to that square again where “he doesn’t have to be town” thing is what gave you away.

[Annoying Prick]

I don't understand your argument. Nowhere have you demonstrated that Aragorn or The Final Girl role has to be town. You're inferring that since his power impacts the killer then he must be town but 1) he has two powers, the daytime gun being one, so being mafia wouldn't render his role useless and 2) nowhere in the rules or in Duck's earlier comment does he say that any archetypes are exempt. Any of them can be the killer as far as we are concerned.

You have just made yourself and Aragorn look more suspicious since you're insisting on a position you can't defend, that The Final Girl role can definitely not be mafia.

[bigboss88]

I don't understand your argument. Nowhere have you demonstrated that Aragorn or The Final Girl role has to be town. You're inferring that since his power impacts the killer then he must be town but 1) he has two powers, the daytime gun being one, so being mafia wouldn't render his role useless and 2) nowhere in the rules or in Duck's earlier comment does he say that any archetypes are exempt. Any of them can be the killer as far as we are concerned.

You have just made yourself and Aragorn look more suspicious since you're insisting on a position you can't defend, that The Final Girl role can definitely not be mafia.

Explain this to me: how can you explain his night power “If they are targeted by The Killer”, please! How can he be targeted by The Killer when they are together in the same team?

[Annoying Prick]

I simply don't think it's impossible that Duck would have made an archetype like that mafia even if it negates one of his powers. Notably I haven't even said we should lynch Aragorn, I've just said that the case for him being town is not as strong as we thought. It's you who has jumped on this as a chance to lynch me.

[bigboss88]

I simply don't think it's impossible that Duck would have made an archetype like that mafia even if it negates one of his powers. Notably I haven't even said we should lynch Aragorn, I've just said that the case for him being town is not as strong as we thought. It's you who has jumped on this as a chance to lynch me.

Nope. I didn’t start suspecting you just now. It was since your choice to lynch Aragorn out of nowhere and you being the first and only voter.

Also, if nobody backs you up after all the evidence I presented, I’m positively sure you’re the last mafia player.

[Annoying Prick]

So you're even suggesting that Agent is definitely mafia and definitely wasn't framed? What's the evidence for that?!

Let's let people read our exchange and decide what they think. I've made my argument. I am not mafia and everything I have said about Aragorn is perfectly reasonable.

[bigboss88]

So you're even suggesting that Agent is definitely mafia and definitely wasn't framed? What's the evidence for that?!

Let's let people read our exchange and decide what they think. I've made my argument. I am not mafia and everything I have said about Aragorn is perfectly reasonable.

I can’t confirm if Agent was framed or not, but I’m dead on if bk wasn’t mafia, then Agent most likely is. At that possibility, with you insisting that Aragorn isn’t a confirmed town, you two are partners in crime.

[Annoying Prick]

So you're even suggesting that Agent is definitely mafia and definitely wasn't framed? What's the evidence for that?!

Let's let people read our exchange and decide what they think. I've made my argument. I am not mafia and everything I have said about Aragorn is perfectly reasonable.

I can’t confirm if Agent was framed or not, but I’m dead on if bk wasn’t mafia, then Agent most likely is. At that possibility, with you insisting that Aragorn isn’t a confirmed town, you two are partners in crime.

Why would BK not being mafia mean that Agent is? There are quite a few other people in the game.

[bigboss88]

So you're even suggesting that Agent is definitely mafia and definitely wasn't framed? What's the evidence for that?!

Let's let people read our exchange and decide what they think. I've made my argument. I am not mafia and everything I have said about Aragorn is perfectly reasonable.

I can’t confirm if Agent was framed or not, but I’m dead on if bk wasn’t mafia, then Agent most likely is. At that possibility, with you insisting that Aragorn isn’t a confirmed town, you two are partners in crime.

Why would BK not being mafia mean that Agent is? There are quite a few other people in the game.

Let’s do a recap: Agent (like yourself with me and Aragorn) accused bk and even went to vote to lynch him out of nowhere. Bk, in response, voted to lynch based on the fact that he chose to lynch him. What made bk suspicious was that he did the very same thing you’re doing. It was his fault that he played without even caring to read the rules. Yet, this time around you’re suggesting something more ridiculous. At least his excuse was that he didn’t read the rules clearly. You, on the other hand, chose to contradict your own post thinking that we won’t look back. Your own defense is what’s actually making you look guilty. You acknowledged that Aragorn was innocent. Now, you’re saying he might be not when everyone knows he is townie! There’s a reason I hadn’t lynched Agent first which is he sounded less guilty and was very careful. Bk wasn’t.

[Annoying Prick]

I was mistaken in thinking he was a guaranteed town. I misunderstood the rules like a lot of people did, including weavo. I said he was a town because I assumed the list of archetypes was a list of town roles but that's not how it works. Since that isn't how it works then there is no reason to take for granted that Aragorn is town since you can be any of those archetypes and be mafia. It's perfectly reasonable to admit to a misunderstanding and renegade on it.

People only "know" he's a town because they made the same assumption I did. My point is that we shouldn't take that for granted since any of those archetypes can be mafia.

I never said something hoping people wouldn't look back lmao. I made a post pretty clearly acknowledging that I had changed my mind because I had misunderstood how the roles work previously. There's been no attempt to conceal the fact that I changed my mind.

But we are going around in circles. Let's wait for someone else to read the thread.