MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Annoying Prick]

I don't really see why the no lynchers would be our prime target. If Null and Aragorn were both town then doesn't it make sense that mafia would want to lynch them? I think maybe we should try to think more broadly than just the day one voting choices, it's almost comical how caught up we are on them.

It's a shame there were barely any lynching votes on the second day.

[black king]

Did anyone learn anything useful overnight?

[starschwar]

Did anyone learn anything useful overnight?

As useful as Freddy's connection to serpent demons, Jason's true nature as a body-jumping parasite, or Michael's loyalty to the Cult of Thorn.  So... no.  Nothing. 

 I hope someone has a decent idea for what to do now, 'cause I've got nothing.

[bigboss88]

Why would he be mafia? Doesn't this confirm he is town? I can only see one role that has such a power and they are town.

And if he is town I think that makes it much more likely that Bigbos88 is too since he was so intent on defending Aragorn and wanted to draw attention to the no lynchers instead of even Null, another town.

Here’s the thing. I was dead on lynching you the second I see “Day 3 begins” because you were the only who voted Aragorn and almost started a campaign to lynch him. After this post, I’m on the fence that Annoying Prick most likely a townie or a mafia who is in a difficult situation for being the only one who voted Aragorn on day 2.

Now let’s answer your question about why the no lynchers are prime suspects at this point. 1. NONE of them is dead. While 2 out of 5 of lynch Aragorn are now dead. 2. Mafia benefited the most from no lynching. It was the safe route for them to being not suspected, but Aragorn jumping the gun (literally) blew it for them. 3. They thought 7 votes alive can easily lynch anyone who voted the confirmed townie on day 1. 4. Their play styles were really suspicious.

So let’s break things. If the mafia are only 2 (which fits the theme of the game tbh), then Aragorn is confirmed townie. I stated Annoying Prick case and prefer to think he’s a townie. Now, Bk is the most sketchy for me. Either he’s playing dumb or he wanted to cover the fact that Aragorn is a confirmed townie by stating he might be mafia! Weavo: I’m beginning to suspect he or star is the silent mafia. Leaning towards Weavo the most if there 3 mafia (which I’m starting to doubt at this point). Agent is a potential candidate as he’s the first to suggest no lynch (I think). Roger is playing very very very safe. 

Now, it would have been very beneficial for us if Aragorn held his horses and didn’t shoot Henry very early, but Aragorn will always be Aragorn. You haven’t changed, my friend! 🤣😜 

I don’t wanna repeat Aragorn’s mistake by killing another town. So I’ll look out for more insight before I make my final call and it’s pretty much obvious who I’m side looking at.

[Agent]

I wonder what Agent thinks about all this.

And yeah my understanding is this confirms Aragorn is a (trigger happy) townie

I think we need some answers Agent doesn't have right now. There's genuinely not much I can say with certainty in this setup. Giving Aragorn a gun was always likely to go like this too. Unless anyone wants to share night info I broadly agree with bb88 and i'll vote for the most logical candidate.

Lynch BK

[black king]

Hey now, just because I'm not in a red dress doesn't mean you get to railroad me this time, Agent


Lynch Agent

At least until we get a real suspect.

[bigboss88]

Well, one of you two is definitely mafia. I’m 100% sure of that now. 🤣 I don’t know what fucking red dress are you talking about, bk. Man, I don’t even wanna know! 🤣 Sorry but I’ll elaborate why I suspect you the most. You’d think that we’ve been playing this game for 8 days now that every player interested in finding out who’s who would have read the roles and rules at least twice to know that Aragorn having a gun means he’s the final girl. So either you knew that and was playing dumb (I’m beginning to think this is 90% the case here as you played the dumb card on day 2 too) or you simply really don’t know what you’re doing (I highly doubt that at this point). 

So yeah, lynch black king as it’s the only way to lynch a mafia on day 3 or 4. If it’s not bk, it’s definitely Agent!

[black king]

The dress is a reference to the last mafia game we played. It was Matrix themed.

[bigboss88]

The dress is a reference to the last mafia game we played. It was Matrix themed.

Well, I’m gonna go ahead and read the whole last game just to know what you guys were up to before I join in! 🤣🤣🤣

[Dirty Duck]

2 votes for black king. 1 vote for Agent.

7 left to vote.