MGF Mafia 3: The Woodsboro Murders

[Dirty Duck]

3 votes for bigboss88. 1 vote for Annoying Prick.

3 left to vote.

[Annoying Prick]

Key word is “was”. He is for a fact the gossip, that does not mean he can’t be mafia - and him acting weird about Weavo’s death tells me something doesn’t make sense. I was riding on you being mafia to be honest but Weavo getting shot in the face kind of solidifies him as suspect to me. That or it’s a poor play, but it’s all we’ve got.

Et tu, Brutus?

Lynch BB88.

I just don't understand how The Gossip killed Weavo during the day phase. We know for a fact that he did it. How?

When he tried to frame me his argument was that he couldn't have been the one to kill Weavo precisely because he is The Gossip. When he realised that argument wasn't going to work because I was confirmed as the Stoner and Duck made it clear BB88 shot Weavo he instead started claiming to have a gun and then claimed that he is some kind of amalgamation of two roles that exists but is unstated in the rules, I guess a mix of The Gossip and The Final Girl. 

Seems like obvious lies but if that last thing is true then I blame Duck for putting that in the game!

Also I keep repeating myself but even his claim to having a gun is odd because the flavour text that Duck wrote clearly describes Weavo as being stabbed and Duck has confirmed that the text does describe what is happening in the game as close as possible.

[Roy]

BB88 and Aragorn need to be lynched even if they are somehow town for killing actual town members. They've made things worse for town at any given opportunity. They're either mafia or really really bad townies.

[Roger]

Roy, Mr Tibbs and I have been the most active of the inactive. The other guy, seems to be consistently inactive. And the night times have been long. I think the fingers should be pointed more towards the inactive than the active. Course, I could be wrong and BB88 could be pulling an insane gotcha.

[Mr. Tibbs]

I just can't see any logic for a townie to stab someone and then try to pretend they didn't tbh. I think maybe we're overthinking this
Lynch BB88

[Roger]

On the event bb88 is a mafia, the action was done during the day. Whatever method of killing was used, is a day action. If bb88 is the class clown, that will only make the most sense. But I still find it interesting that the moment some inactive members start talking, murder is afoot. I don't know, seems very convenient.

[starschwar]

I've tried keeping my big mouth shut - especially when I don't have any new evidence to contribute. I've let more seasoned and rational minds than mine make sense of this.  Right now, it looks like the only way we're getting answers is to go in this specific direction.  I've been wrong before, but if we don't get this over with, the killers are going to make short work of the rest of us.

Lynch BB88

[Dirty Duck]

5 votes for bigboss88. 1 vote for Annoying Prick.

DAY FOUR ENDS

Lynch bigboss88

Despite The Deputy's sacrifice to provide us with something to go on, it still took the room as long as usual to decide that the man who just gutted him in front of us all might have in fact been a killer...

He waved the knife frantically and pleaded innocence as the mob closed in on him but it was too late. Someone grabbed his wrist and wrestled the knife from his grip. The crowd held him as he struggled, the knife swung down and cleaved through his stomach, making a large gouge as it was sliced back upwards. He shook uncontrollably as the contents of his intestines spilled out onto the floor below.

To everyone's surprise he stayed conscious long enough to utter a final sentence:
"My mom and dad are gonna be so mad at me..."
His body went heavy. The crowd dropped him to the floor where he landed with a thud.

The knife confirmed without a shadow of a doubt, we'd killed a killer.

NIGHT FOUR ENDS

ALIVE (6):
Roger
starschwar
Annoying Prick
Mr. Tibbs
Aragorn
Roy
DEAD:
Jassassino (The Reporter) Night Killed Night 1
Null (The Sheriff) Shot Day Two
Wayno (The Prime Suspect) Night Killed Night 2
black king (The Horror Nerd) Lynched Day 3
Agent (The Jock) Night Killed Night 3 Ghostface Costume
weavo (The Deputy) Day Killed Day 4
bigboss88 (The Class Clown) Lynched Day 4 Knife

It is now the night phase. Please PM me your night actions if you have them.

[Aragorn]

BB88 and Aragorn need to be lynched even if they are somehow town for killing actual town members. They've made things worse for town at any given opportunity. They're either mafia or really really bad townies.